8 Things You Should Know: Rice & Water

8 Things You Should Know: Rice & Water

By Debra Tan, Katie Tsang, Dawn McGregor 9 April, 2014

China is the #1 global producer of rice. Here are 8 things you should know about rice & water

Rice as a dominant food staple can be traced back to as long as 4,000 years ago and today it still feeds more than half of the world’s population. The fact that to “eat rice” is an equivalent to consume a meal in many Asian cultures highlights its importance.
Here are 8 things you should know about rice & water in China:

1. China is the #1 rice producer globally

In 2012, 720 million tonnes of rice was produced globally. Asia dominates rice production –  there is only one non-Asian country (Brazil #9) amongst the Top 10, which produced 615 million tonnes or 85% of global rice. The US is the next non-Asian ranked rice producing country at #13 and produced 9 million tonnes or 1.3% of total global production.
China, the #1 producer has a 28% global market share at 204 million tonnes, whilst India ranked #2 produced 153 million tonnes (21%). Together, China & India not only account for half the world’s population but also half of the world’s production of rice. Yet, they are the #2 and #1 most water stressed countries globally – given limited water resources, can rice continue to be Asia’s staple?

2. China farmland dedicated to rice = size of Italy; 52% of these lands are in water scarce & stressed provinces

Rice is clearly a key staple in China. Other key grains grown are wheat and corn (see graph). In 2012, China produced around 151kg of rice and corn per capita compared to 89kg of wheat per capita.
This rice output came from around 30 million hectares of sown land which is equivalent to the size of Italy. Analysis of rice sown land and the availability of water resources show that 13% of these lands lie in the Dry 11 and 39% in the At Risk 9. In other words, 52% of China’s farmland dedicated to rice lie in water scarce & water stressed provinces.

Rice is obviously water intensive (images of rice paddy fields spring to mind) but just how much water does rice need?

3. Rice = thirsty grain; but swapping to more wheat/corn might not work

Rice is the most water intensive key grain (see graph below). The global average virtual water content is 2,300 litres in 1kg of rice.
           
Perhaps we should switch out of rice into other grains?
However, as highlighted in HSBC’s No Water, No Food Report, less thirsty grains such as corn and wheat are even more exposed to water scarcity than rice with 84% of China’s corn sown land and 87% of China’s wheat sown land in water scarce and water stressed regions (see HSBC graph).

At least the good news is that China appears to be more “water-efficient” in producing rice, only using 1,321 litres per kilo of rice compared to the world average (according to Arjen Y Hoekstra & Ashok K Chapagam). Also, China is turning towards agritech to boost rice yields per drop of water used (see later).

4. Pollution from excessive fertiliser use: Top 5 Rice Producers with 51% of China’s rice output use 9 million tonnes of fertiliser less than the total fertiliser use of the USA

Compounding China’s water scarcity issue is water and soil pollution. Agriculture is the most polluting industry through its excessive use of chemical fertilisers and pesticide. This is a vicious cycle as pollution exacerbates already limited water resources and degrades soil quality resulting in the withdrawal of land for farm use. Already around 3.33 million hectares of farmland is too polluted to grow crops and has been withdrawn from use last year (more on the state of China’s agriculture here).

Fertiliser has been used to boost yields. For rice, the Top 5 Rice Producing Provinces are Hunan, Heilongjiang, Jiangxi, Jiangsu & Hubei. Together, they accounted for around 51% of total national rice output in 2012. However, a total of 13 million tonnes of chemical fertiliser was used in agriculture in the Top 5 Rice Producing Provinces (see table).
While there is no detailed breakdown of which crops these fertilisers were applied to, the fact that the amount used in these 5 provinces is only 9 million tonnes less than the 2011 total US fertiliser use should give an idea of the extent of liberal fertiliser application.

5. “Cadmium Rice” and exposure to industrial pollution: 51% of China’s rice produced in provinces which account for 60% of national cadmium discharge

Not only is rice exposed to nonpoint source pollution from excessive fertiliser use, it is also exposed to industrial wastewater pollution (more on heavy metals discharge in China here). According to the HSBC No Water, No Food Report, “Three-fifths of China’s sown area is exposed to 85% of the nation’s heavy metal discharge – with rice the most exposed grain and Hunan the most exposed province”.
Indeed, over half of China’s rice output is grown in provinces which account for a significant share of the total national heavy metals discharged in wastewater: Lead (51%), Mercury (55%), Cadmium (60%), Chromium (31%) and Arsenic (56%).

“Three-fifths of China’s sown area is exposed to 85% of the nation’s heavy metal discharge – with rice the most exposed grain and Hunan the most exposed province”

HSBC No Water, No Food

March 2014

Rice samples with alarming levels of cadmium found caused much concern amongst the Chinese public. A Chinese Academy of Science, Nanjing Agricultural University Study in 2007 estimated that 10% of rice sampled had excessive levels of cadmium from soil pollution.
Hunan and Jiangxi were amongst the provinces highlighted. This is not surprising as Hunan is the #1 ranked province across all five heavy metal categories with the exception of chromium where Henan comes up top. Hunan is the #1 rice producing province with 13% of national rice production.
On weibo, there have been almost half million posts specifically related to cadmium rice. The posts expressed deep concern about heavy metals in rice and worries over farmers saying that they would not eat their own rice.

Read a first-hand account of cadmium rice & cancer villages in our interview with award-winning photographer Lu Guang here. Lu Guang’s photographs have been instrumental in drawing attention to this issue.
With rising food safety concerns, central government is turning their attention towards tackling agricultural and soil pollution (more here). But soil remediation takes time … so in the meantime, where can China get more “safe” rice?

 6. Water scarcity & food safety concerns in China could significantly shift global rice trade

Currently, although China is a net importer of rice, it is not amongst the large importers of rice. According to FAO, China imported 0.6 million tonnes placing it as the #18 largest importer in 2011. This is a mere 0.3% of its national rice output.
The top 3 rice importing countries were Indonesia, Nigeria and Bangladesh with 2.8 million tonnes, 2.2 million tonnes and 1.3 million tonnes respectively. On the other hand, the top 3 rice exporters were Thailand (10.7 million tonnes), Vietnam (7.1 million tonnes) and India (5.0 million tonnes) – collectively equivalent to around 11% of China’s annual rice output.
Around 32 million tonnes or 16% of China’s rice was produced in the Dry 11. This is 3x the rice exported by Thailand, the #1 exporter (see map). Given the size of China’s rice output, water scarcity & food safety concerns in China could significantly shift global trade in rice.

Given that Thailand’s rice production is close to maximum capacity, can other rice growing countries support China’s rice appetite? Or is the way forward a change in diet?

7. Go on a diet! Government says eat more grain & less meat

A diet mix comparison amongst the G20 countries shows that Asian diets are more rice intensive than western diets (see graph). Amongst the Asian countries, Indonesians have the largest daily per capita calorie intake from rice at 48%, whilst the Chinese derive 26% of their daily calories from rice. It is clear from the graph that the Chinese are the top meat eaters amongst the Asians.

However, meat is more water intensive and in February 2014, State Council issued the New Guidelines on China’s Food & Nutrition Development 2014-2020 advocating a change in diet to increase grain mix to >50% and fats <30%, and 78g of proteins (more on this here).
Given concerns over “cadmium rice” and limited possibility of switching to wheat and corn due to their high exposure to water scarcity, China may have no choice but to turn to imports to support it “more-grain-less-meat” diet. HSBC thinks so … read their opinion here.

8. Agritech, more hybrids and better strategies needed to face climate change

China can turn to rice imports make up for deficits in domestic production but the amount that it may be able to import may be limited. Also, food security is of paramount importance and as China wants to maintain 95% grain self-sufficiency, it is looking towards agritech to provide solutions. Ultimately, to ensure rice security, China needs to develop a climate change adaptation strategy.

China is already one of the more efficient rice growers and achieves more than 7 tonnes of rice per hectare while India and Thailand average only around 3 tonnes per hectare.

Syngenta 2011 Annual Report

China is already one of the more efficient rice growers and achieves more than 7 tonnes of rice per hectare while India and Thailand average only around 3 tonnes per hectare. Also, water use in rice is relatively efficient (see point #3); as such, China is turning towards hybrid seeds that produce more crop-per-drop. Hybrids are also being developed as part of climate change adaption. Extreme weather is becoming more common in China – it needs to sow extreme weather resistant rice strains that are able to withstand flooding, droughts as well as hybrids that can withstand both floods & droughts within a single planting season. In 2012, hybrid rice accounted for 55.4 – 59.7% of China’s total rice sown area.
The International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) is testing to combine climate change tolerant breeds of rice such as: “Salinas” that grow on saline seawater, “Sahod Ulan” for rain-fed farms and the flood-resistant “Submarino”. IRRI is also conducting research on pesticides that are able to minimize damage to rice crops by the destructive brown planthopper (a rice crop pest prevalent in Asia).

Such hybrids should also help to reduce the use of pesticides plus reduce the effect of the shift in Pacific Decadal Oscillation ocean cycle, which is expected to make Northern China wetter and the South drier (more on this in our review “Food, Weather & Water Heading North”). This may be good news for the thirsty North but given that the majority of rice is grown in the South, rice production is likely to be affected.

Although this march towards agritech is encouraging, there is still a long way to go. Xu Yinlong (a member of the Scientific Steering Committee leading the UNEP’s Programme of Research on Climate Change Vulnerability, Impacts and Adaptation) in his interview with China Dialogue says that there is still no clear understanding of what adaptation to climate change is in China. Xu believes that adaptation planning is required at national level across ministries and sectors before any coordinated action in order to be effective.
Let’s hope we get there – we like our rice!

Further Reading

• The State of China’s Agriculture – China’s limited water and arable land plus rampant water pollution not only exacerbate water scarcity, but also raises concerns over food safety & food security. Get the latest update on agriculture & water and see why these policies matter for global trade
• Heavy Metals & Agriculture – Check out China Water Risk’s overview of the status of heavy metals discharge into wastewater, priority provinces, overlap with agriculture sown lands, crops exposed and industries targeted for clean-up
• Crying Lands: China’s Polluted Waterscapes – Award-winning photographer Lu Guang shares his journey in documenting  sensitive social, health & environmental issues in China. See the tangible linkages through his heart-rending and insightful photographs
• Water Pollution Could Lead to More Trade – Upon the publication of No Water, No Food – ensuring food safety & food security in China, HSBC’s Wai-Shin Chan tells us why China’s war on pollution, the need for self-sufficiency may result in more agri trade
• Global Agriculture & Water Security – With more than 25% of global agriculture grown in high water stress areas, tension between global crop production & water supply is forecasted to grow. WRI’s Frances Gassert tells us why we must look at food and water together
• The War on Water Pollution  – Premier Li Keqiang has just declared war on pollution. Tan expands on the government’s stratagems & offensives and fundamental changes required to shore up the MEP’s arsenal in order to wage a successful war
• Food, Weather & Water Heading North  – Global weather patterns have shifted with major implications for agriculture. Find out what it means for the sector if food, water and weather are all heading North in China